In one worked reconciliation, expenses came in 17% under budget and the landlord still owed one...
You renewed the tenant. Did you renew their reimbursements?

A renewal gets negotiated as a leasing deal: term, rent, maybe a tenant improvement allowance. The lease also restates how the tenant pays for operating expenses, and that part is the one budgets leave behind. Nobody notices until the reconciliation the following spring.
TL;DR
- A renewal is two events: a new rent schedule and, often, new recovery terms. Budgets tend to capture the first and assume the second.
- What changes most often at renewal: the base year and the cap that hangs off it, the pro rata share, the reimbursement method, and concessions a broker negotiated.
- A renewal budgeted without its recovery terms is billed wrong all year through monthly estimates. The gap shows up at reconciliation, 90 to 120 days after year-end for a calendar-year lease.
- Before you lock the 2027 budget, list every renewal signed since last budget season and check each one’s recovery setup against the signed lease.
A renewal is two events
When a tenant renews, the conversation is about term and rent. Leasing negotiates it, asset management approves it, and the new rent schedule goes into the budget. That part rarely gets missed, because rent is the line everyone watches.
The renewal also restates how the tenant pays for operating expenses, and that part changes more often than people expect. If the budget carries the old recovery setup into the new term, or drops it, the tenant’s estimates for the coming year are wrong from the first invoice. Nothing flags it when you enter it. The rent schedule looks right, the occupancy looks right, and the error sits in a section nobody opens until spring.
What tends to change at renewal
The base year, and the cap that hangs off it
In a base year lease, a renewal often resets the base year to the first year of the new term, so the tenant pays only increases over the new base. When the base year resets, a controllable expense cap usually resets from that year too. Carrying the original cap or the original base forward under-bills the tenant for the rest of the term. We covered the cap side of this in five recovery settings to check before you lock the 2027 budget.
The pro rata share
If the building has been remeasured since the original lease, or the tenant took on or gave back space, the share changes. Load factors move as tenants take or give back common area, so a share copied from the old lease bills the wrong slice of every pool, every month.
The reimbursement method
A tenant can move from triple net to a base year structure at renewal, or the other way. Because the change starts on the renewal date, a mid-year renewal means the first months follow the old method and the rest follow the new one.
“If you had a midyear renewal, you have to show them on two separate rows of the rent roll, because the lease start and end date drives the recovery language.”
Kathy Lim, speaking at a BOMA session on CAM reconciliation
Concessions
Brokers negotiate recoveries too: an excluded expense, a lower cap, a fixed CAM charge, a few months of free reimbursements. In one of our training sessions the example was a renewal whose broker had negotiated electrical out of the tenant’s recoveries for the new term. These sit in the operating expense section of the lease, not in the rent rider, and they are the easiest terms to miss.
Why you find out in April
The budget feeds the estimate letters, which for calendar-year operators go out around November. Kevin Whalen of Cushman & Wakefield describes November as the month to “wrap up budgets, issue estimate letters for the following year.” Tenants then pay those estimates monthly for twelve months.
The reconciliation comes after year-end. Most leases give the landlord 90 to 120 days, which for a calendar-year lease lands between the end of March and the end of April. That is the first time actual expenses get compared with what each tenant was billed, and the first time a renewal set up on the old terms turns into a number: a balance the tenant didn’t expect, or a refund the owner didn’t budget. Either one invites a tenant audit.
A renewal that never made it into the budget at all shows up differently. The tenant still occupies the space, but the recovery calculation treats the months after the old expiration as empty, so the shortfall lands in vacancy and reads like a leasing problem rather than a setup error. We wrote about that pattern in where CAM reconciliation errors come from.
How it works in Kardin
In Kardin, you renew a tenant by applying a leasing assumption on expiration. That adds a new rent roll row for the same suite, starting the day after the old lease ends, and fills in the rent schedule, tenant improvements and leasing commissions from the assumption.
The reimbursements are set fresh for the new term, not copied from the old lease, because that’s the part of a renewal most likely to change. You set the reimbursement method for each pool, check the pro rata share (Kardin calculates it from the lease’s rentable square feet against the building’s, and you can override it when the lease states a different number), and assign the tenant an expense schedule. If the renewal carries its own exception, like that excluded electrical, you create a new expense code for it, so one tenant’s concession doesn’t change anyone else’s schedule.
Two reports confirm it took. The Occupancy Summary shows whether the renewal picks up where the old lease ends. The Recoveries Calculation shows the tenant’s share for each part of the year, so a July renewal reads as two half-year periods, each on its own terms.
A renewal check before you lock the 2027 budget
- Pull every renewal signed since last budget season: from leasing’s list or the signed documents, not from the budget file. A renewal that never made it into the budget won’t show up by looking at the budget.
- Read the operating expense section, not just the rent rider. The recovery terms live there: the base year, the cap, the share and any exceptions.
- Match four settings to the signed renewal: base year, cap starting point, pro rata share and reimbursement method.
- Look for concessions: excluded expenses, a fixed CAM charge, a lower cap or months of free reimbursements.
- Check the renewal date on the reports. The occupancy view should show the renewal picking up the day after the old lease ends, with no gap and no overlap, and the recovery calculation should split the year at that date.
If you want to see what the finished output looks like, our Sample Reports page has a recoveries calculation and a combined tenant statement you can open without signing up. The CRE budget calendar has the rest of the year, month by month.
Frequently asked questions
Does a lease renewal reset the base year?
Often, in a base year lease, but only when the renewal says so. Many renewals move the base year to the first year of the new term, which means the tenant pays only increases over the new base. If the base year resets, any controllable expense cap tied to it usually resets from that year as well. The signed renewal decides both, so read its operating expense section before you budget.
Why do renewals cause CAM reconciliation errors?
Because the rent terms get entered and the recovery terms get assumed. The new rent schedule is the part everyone negotiates and checks. The base year, pro rata share, reimbursement method and any expense concessions sit in a different section of the lease, and when the budget carries the old setup forward, the tenant’s estimates are wrong for the whole year.
How do you budget a tenant that renews mid-year?
As two periods. The months before the renewal date follow the old lease and the months after follow the new one, including any change in pro rata share or reimbursement method. In Kardin that means two rent roll rows for the same suite, because the lease start and end dates determine which recovery terms apply.
When does a missed renewal setup show up?
At reconciliation. Tenants pay monthly estimates all year based on the budget, and for a calendar-year lease the reconciliation statement is usually due 90 to 120 days after year-end, so end of March to end of April. That is when an under-billed or over-billed renewal turns into a balance due or a refund, and when the tenant can ask to audit it.
Sources
- Kathy Lim, BOMA Power Hour on CAM reconciliation best practices (Kardin recording of a software-agnostic practitioner session). The two-row treatment of a mid-year renewal and the base year and cap reset. The quotation is lightly edited for clarity.
- Kardin training archive: Q1 Reforecast Process, Year-End CAM Reconciliations, Commercial Recovery Setup, and the Office-Industrial recoveries session. How a renewal is applied through a leasing assumption, what it fills in and what it doesn’t, pro rata share overrides after remeasurement, the excluded-electrical example, and the reports used to check a renewal.
- Kevin Whalen, Senior Managing Director, Cushman & Wakefield, quoted in Commercial Property Executive, July 2026, on November as the month to wrap up budgets and issue estimate letters.
- Reconciliation delivery windows of 90 to 120 days after fiscal year-end: CREModels and RE BackOffice. The lease governs in every case.